TRANSMISSION // 2611.21448v1
Can one principle explain why quantum theory works?
Source published
A new theoretical paper argues that quantum probabilities follow from ideal measurements plus a principle that every allowed correlation is physically possible.

Quantum theory’s rules are remarkably successful, but why should nature follow the Hilbert-space mathematics and Born rule? Adán Cabello’s preprint proposes an answer built from two ideas: measurements that are repeatable and minimally disturbing, and a “plenitude” principle saying that every correlation allowed under those conditions can occur.
A proposed route to quantum theory
Quantum mechanics gives precise rules for predicting the probabilities of measurement outcomes. Its mathematical framework—the Hilbert space and the Born rule—works extremely well, but physicists have long asked whether those rules can be derived from simpler physical principles.
In this theoretical paper, Adán Cabello proposes a principle called plenitude of ideal correlations, or PIC. The argument is that quantum correlations emerge if a theory meets two requirements: every observable has an ideal way to measure it, and every correlation that is possible in such a theory is physically realizable.
An ideal measurement, as the paper defines it, has two operational properties. Repeat it immediately on the same system and it gives the same outcome; and it does not disturb any observable compatible with it. “Compatible” means that the observables can be jointly measured. These are assumptions about what measurements a theory permits—not a report of a new laboratory test.
From exclusivity to quantum probabilities
The paper’s main tool is the exclusivity graph. In this mathematical representation, each vertex stands for a possible event, while an edge connects two events that cannot both occur. For example, two distinct outcomes of the same measurement are mutually exclusive.
Ideal measurements impose a basic probability constraint: the probabilities of any collection of pairwise exclusive events cannot add up to more than one. The paper argues that this constraint applies not only to a single experiment but also to combined experiments and multiple independent copies. Correlations that look acceptable in one setting may be ruled out when placed in a larger combined setting.
Cabello develops this reasoning in stages. First, the paper argues that ideal measurements imply that sets of pairwise compatible observables can be jointly measured, and that exclusive events obey the probability bound. It then uses graph-based mathematical results to show that demanding the bound across the relevant combinations selects the same correlation sets as quantum theory for every finite exclusivity graph. The paper extends the result to measurement scenarios, including Bell scenarios, and argues that the resulting structure gives the Hilbert-space formalism and Born-rule probabilities.
The central mathematical claim is therefore not simply that quantum theory obeys a sensible constraint. It is that, across these scenarios, the constraint together with PIC picks out the quantum possibilities: correlations allowed by the quantum formalism are realizable, while alternatives outside the quantum set are excluded.
What the result does—and does not—establish
This is a derivation within a framework of probabilistic theories, not an experimental discovery that quantum mechanics has been replaced or independently verified. PIC carries substantial weight: it says that no additional physical restriction prevents correlations that the framework permits. The existence of ideal measurements for every observable is also a premise. The paper motivates these assumptions, but the derivation does not by itself demonstrate that nature must adopt them.
There is also an important technical qualification. The paper identifies the commuting quantum correlation set as the result in general. In finite-dimensional Hilbert spaces, this agrees with the familiar tensor-product description. In infinite dimensions, the paper notes that the commuting set can be larger. Its conclusion should therefore not be casually paraphrased as recovering exactly the same set under every formulation of quantum theory.
The work is a mathematical argument, not a new data set or a measurement campaign. Its force depends on the definitions, assumptions and proofs in the manuscript, and readers should distinguish the established conditional result from the author’s broader interpretation of it as an explanation of the world. The paper itself says that further questions remain, including what experimental conditions are needed to realize all the possibilities the formalism permits.
The preprint identifies itself as a refined version of earlier results, with additional intermediate theorems and revised proofs. It is hosted on arXiv and, in the supplied source, is not identified as peer-reviewed. As with any preprint, its claims should be read as work open to expert scrutiny rather than as settled consensus. The source text also notes that the commuting and tensor-product sets differ in some infinite-dimensional scenarios, a point that matters when interpreting how broadly the result recovers quantum theory.
- quantum foundations
- quantum theory
- Born rule
- ideal measurement
- quantum correlations
- contextuality
Related reading
Automatically matched by shared topic keywords. These links do not imply that the sources agree or establish a consensus.
Could timeless shapes offer a route beyond quantum theory?
Source published
Shared keywords: quantum foundations
A transformer that can show which words shaped its answer
Source published
Shared keywords: born rule
Why causal order may not behave like a quantum observable
Source published
Shared keywords: quantum foundations
Quantum decay reversal is limited by an environment’s memory, preprint argues
Source published
Shared keywords: quantum foundations
Could trapped light retain the imprint of past interactions?
Source published
Shared keywords: quantum correlations